Best electric bikes for hunting: Quiet and powerful rides

Remember that feeling when you finally spotted that buck, heart pounding, rifle ready, only to realize you were miles away from your truck, exhaustion creeping in? Been there! The struggle of hauling gear, navigating rough terrain, and trying to maintain stealth – it can make even the most dedicated hunter consider hanging up their boots. But what if there was a way to conquer those challenges and truly maximize your time in the field? What if you could move silently, effortlessly, and cover more ground than ever before?

That’s where the magic of electric bikes comes in, especially when you’re looking for the best electric bikes for hunting. This comprehensive guide is designed to cut through the noise and equip you with the knowledge to choose the perfect e-bike for your hunting adventures. We’ll explore top-rated models, dissect key features, and provide valuable insights to ensure your next hunt is not only successful but also enjoyable. Let’s get ready to redefine your hunting experience!

We will review the best electric bikes for hunting later in this article. But before that, take a look at some relevant products on Amazon:

Last update on 2025-04-19 / Affiliate links / #CommissionsEarned / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Ready to Ride? The Electric Hunting Bike Revolution is Here

Picture this: dawn is breaking, the air is crisp, and instead of the rumble of an ATV, you hear only the quiet whir of an electric motor as you glide silently through the woods. Hunting is changing, and the rise of electric bikes is a huge part of that shift. Gone are the days of noisy treks that announce your arrival to every deer within a mile radius. Now, you can navigate trails with minimal disturbance, covering more ground and increasing your chances of that perfect shot. Plus, who wouldn’t want to swap an expensive gas-guzzler for an efficient, eco-friendly alternative?

But with so many options flooding the market, finding the best electric bikes for hunting can feel like navigating a dense forest without a map. That’s where we come in! We’ll guide you through the key features to consider – things like motor power, battery life, tire type, and cargo capacity. Because let’s be honest, the best e-bike isn’t just about stealth; it’s about hauling your gear, your harvest, and yourself back to camp comfortably and safely.

Think about how far you typically travel during a hunt. A study found that hunters who use motorized vehicles cover an average of 5 miles per hunt. This shows why having the right range and the appropriate motor for challenging terrain is necessary. So, don’t just jump on the first e-bike you see with camouflage paint.

In the following sections, we’ll dive deep into the features that separate the wheat from the chaff, offering practical advice and highlighting some of the top contenders that could redefine your hunting experience. Consider this your comprehensive guide to choosing the best electric bikes for hunting, ensuring your next trip is both successful and sustainable.

Top 5 Best Electric Bikes For Hunting

Rambo Bikes R750XP

The Rambo Bikes R750XP is a workhorse built for serious hunters. This e-bike boasts a powerful 750-watt motor that can conquer tough terrain, hauling your gear and game with ease. Its sturdy frame and all-terrain tires provide stability and traction on uneven surfaces, making it perfect for navigating dense woods and rocky trails. The R750XP’s impressive battery life ensures you can stay out in the field longer without worrying about running out of juice, a huge plus for those all-day hunts.

This e-bike isn’t just about power; it also offers a comfortable and customizable riding experience. With adjustable handlebars and seat, you can find the perfect fit for your body type. The integrated digital display keeps you informed about your speed, battery level, and distance traveled. Plus, the included rear rack provides ample space for carrying your hunting essentials, transforming it into a true hunting companion.

QuietKat Jeep Rubicon E-Bike

The QuietKat Jeep Rubicon e-bike is the ultimate off-road machine, co-engineered with Jeep for unparalleled performance. This beast is equipped with a powerful motor and premium suspension system, allowing you to tackle the most challenging terrains with confidence. Its fat tires provide exceptional grip and stability, making it ideal for navigating mud, snow, and sand. The Jeep Rubicon is designed for serious hunters who demand the best in durability and capability.

Beyond its ruggedness, this e-bike offers a surprisingly smooth and comfortable ride. The high-end components and thoughtful design ensure that every journey is enjoyable, even when traversing rough terrain. The integrated lighting system enhances visibility in low-light conditions, while the multiple riding modes allow you to customize your experience based on the terrain and your desired level of assistance. This is a top-tier e-bike for serious hunters.

Bakcou Mule

The Bakcou Mule is an exceptional electric hunting bike specifically engineered for rugged backwoods adventures. This beast is armed with a robust motor designed to effortlessly climb steep hills and haul heavy loads. Its durable frame and puncture-resistant tires ensure reliability and longevity, even in the most demanding environments. The Mule is a trustworthy partner for any hunter venturing deep into the wild.

The Bakcou Mule doesn’t skimp on comfort either. It is designed with a comfortable seat and upright riding position that minimizes fatigue on long rides. The integrated cargo rack allows you to carry essential gear, freeing you to focus on the hunt. Its quiet operation is a significant benefit, allowing you to move stealthily through the woods without spooking game. This e-bike is a fantastic choice for serious hunters seeking a reliable and comfortable ride.

Surface 604 Boar Hunter

The Surface 604 Boar Hunter is a powerful and versatile e-bike designed to handle a variety of hunting terrains. Its robust motor delivers impressive torque, making it easy to conquer steep inclines and navigate through thick brush. The Boar Hunter’s sturdy frame and all-terrain tires provide excellent stability and traction, ensuring a smooth and controlled ride even on challenging trails.

Beyond its power and durability, the Boar Hunter offers a comfortable and user-friendly experience. The adjustable components allow you to customize the fit to your preferences, while the intuitive controls make it easy to manage the bike’s settings. The integrated rear rack provides ample storage space for your hunting gear. With its balance of performance, comfort, and practicality, the Boar Hunter is an excellent choice for hunters of all skill levels.

Rambo Bikes Rampage 1000 XPC

The Rambo Bikes Rampage 1000 XPC is an incredibly powerful e-bike built for the most demanding hunting scenarios. This machine boasts a high-performance motor that delivers unmatched torque and acceleration, allowing you to conquer the toughest terrain with ease. Its robust frame and premium components ensure exceptional durability and reliability, even under extreme conditions. The Rampage is the ultimate choice for hunters who need uncompromising performance.

Despite its raw power, the Rampage also offers a comfortable and controlled riding experience. The advanced suspension system absorbs bumps and vibrations, providing a smooth and stable ride. The ergonomic design and adjustable components allow you to dial in the perfect fit for your body type. With its combination of power, comfort, and durability, the Rampage is a top-of-the-line e-bike that will take your hunting adventures to the next level.

Why Electric Bikes are Becoming Essential for Hunters

Imagine this: You’re up before dawn, the crisp air biting at your cheeks. You’ve got your gear, your stand, and a heart full of anticipation for a successful hunt. But the trailhead is miles away, and the thought of trudging through the underbrush, sweating and potentially spooking game before you even set up, is less than appealing. This is where the best electric bikes for hunting come into play, transforming a challenging trek into a smooth, quiet ride.

Electric bikes offer a distinct advantage by minimizing your scent profile and allowing you to cover more ground efficiently. Think about reaching those remote, less pressured hunting spots that others can’t easily access. No more huffing and puffing, alerting every deer in the county to your presence. With an e-bike, you can glide silently along trails, maximizing your chances of a clean and undisturbed hunt. The powerful motor assists you in hauling your gear, making even steep inclines manageable.

Beyond the hunt itself, consider the logistical benefits. Electric bikes reduce your reliance on gas-guzzling trucks and ATVs, saving you money on fuel and maintenance. They’re also environmentally friendly, leaving a smaller footprint on the land you cherish. Plus, many models are equipped with features like cargo racks and integrated lighting, further enhancing their utility.

Investing in an electric hunting bike isn’t just about making the hunt easier; it’s about enhancing the overall experience. It’s about accessing new hunting grounds, reducing your impact on the environment, and maximizing your chances of a successful and enjoyable hunt. It’s time to embrace the future of hunting and discover the power and potential of the best electric bikes for hunting.

Essential Accessories to Enhance Your Hunting E-Bike Experience

So, you’ve got your shiny new electric hunting bike. Awesome! But to truly maximize its potential and make your hunting trips smoother and more effective, you’ll want to consider some essential accessories. Think of it like this: the e-bike is the engine, and the accessories are the finely tuned parts that make the whole machine purr.

One of the first things you’ll probably want to address is storage. Hunting often involves carrying gear, and a good set of panniers or a rear rack with a basket can make a world of difference. Imagine trying to navigate a tricky trail while balancing a rifle and a backpack – not ideal! Durable, weather-resistant storage solutions will keep your equipment safe and secure, allowing you to focus on the hunt.

Safety is paramount, especially when riding in remote areas. A bright headlight and taillight are non-negotiable, particularly if you’re riding during dawn or dusk. Consider also investing in a high-quality helmet and potentially even a reflective vest. Remember, being seen is just as important as seeing where you’re going.

Finally, don’t overlook the importance of maintenance. A simple tool kit with tire levers, a multi-tool, and a small pump can be a lifesaver if you encounter a flat tire or need to make minor adjustments in the field. Just like your hunting rifle, your e-bike needs to be properly maintained to perform reliably when you need it most.

Understanding E-Bike Motor and Battery Types for Hunting

Navigating the world of e-bike motors and batteries can feel overwhelming, but understanding the basics is crucial for choosing the right bike for your hunting needs. Different motors offer varying levels of power and efficiency, while battery capacity directly impacts how far you can travel on a single charge. Think of it like choosing the right engine for a truck – you need enough power to haul your gear, but also good fuel efficiency to get you where you need to go.

When it comes to motors, you’ll generally encounter hub motors and mid-drive motors. Hub motors are located in the wheel hub and offer a more affordable option, while mid-drive motors are positioned near the pedals and provide a more natural riding feel and improved weight distribution. Consider the terrain you’ll be hunting in. If you’re tackling steep hills or rough terrain, a mid-drive motor will generally offer better performance.

Battery capacity is measured in watt-hours (Wh). A higher Wh rating means a longer range. Think about the distances you typically cover during a hunt. Do you usually stay within a few miles of your starting point, or do you venture further into the wilderness? Choose a battery with enough capacity to comfortably handle your longest anticipated rides, with a little extra in reserve for unexpected situations.

Different battery chemistries also exist, with lithium-ion being the most common. Lithium-ion batteries offer a good balance of energy density, lifespan, and cost. Pay attention to the battery’s voltage and amperage, as these factors also affect performance. A higher voltage typically translates to more power, while amperage relates to the battery’s discharge rate.

Legal Considerations and Regulations for Hunting with E-Bikes

Before you hit the trails with your electric hunting bike, it’s absolutely essential to understand the local laws and regulations governing their use. Ignorance of the law is no excuse, and you don’t want to risk fines, confiscation of your bike, or even more serious penalties. Think of it like knowing the hunting seasons and bag limits – you need to be aware of the rules to hunt ethically and legally.

Many states and jurisdictions have specific regulations regarding where e-bikes are allowed. Some areas may treat e-bikes like traditional bicycles, allowing them on bike paths and trails, while others may restrict them to roads and designated OHV (Off-Highway Vehicle) areas. Check with your local Department of Natural Resources or Fish and Wildlife Agency to get the most up-to-date information.

Pay close attention to motor power restrictions. Some regulations limit the maximum wattage of e-bike motors allowed in certain areas. Exceeding these limits could result in a violation. Also, be aware of any restrictions on e-bike speed, particularly in areas where they are allowed on bike paths shared with pedestrians.

Hunting with an e-bike may also be subject to specific rules. Some jurisdictions may prohibit using an e-bike to pursue or harvest game, while others may have restrictions on when and where e-bikes can be used for hunting. Always check the hunting regulations for the specific area you plan to hunt in.

Maintenance Tips to Keep Your Hunting E-Bike in Top Shape

Just like any piece of essential hunting equipment, your e-bike requires regular maintenance to ensure it performs reliably and lasts for years to come. Neglecting maintenance can lead to breakdowns in the field, shorten the lifespan of your bike, and potentially compromise your safety. Think of it like caring for your hunting rifle – regular cleaning and lubrication are essential to keep it functioning properly.

One of the most important maintenance tasks is regularly checking and maintaining your tires. Ensure they are properly inflated to the recommended pressure, and inspect them for cuts, abrasions, or embedded objects. Replace worn tires promptly to maintain optimal traction and prevent flats. Consider using tire sealant to help prevent punctures.

Pay attention to the chain. Keep it clean and lubricated to ensure smooth shifting and prevent premature wear. A dirty or dry chain can also affect the efficiency of your motor and battery. Use a chain cleaner to remove dirt and grime, and then apply a good quality chain lubricant.

Regularly inspect your brakes. Ensure the brake pads have sufficient thickness and that the brake levers feel firm and responsive. Replace worn brake pads immediately. Also, check the brake cables for fraying or damage. If you have hydraulic brakes, inspect the brake lines for leaks.

Finally, don’t forget about the battery. Store it in a cool, dry place when not in use. Avoid leaving it fully charged or fully discharged for extended periods, as this can shorten its lifespan. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for charging and storing the battery.

Your Ultimate Guide to Finding the Best Electric Bikes For Hunting

Hey there, fellow outdoor enthusiast! Ready to revolutionize your hunting game? I’m guessing you’re looking into electric bikes, and let me tell you, you’re on the right track. Using the best electric bikes for hunting can seriously change the way you approach the wilderness. But with so many options out there, picking the right one can feel overwhelming. Don’t sweat it! This guide is here to break down everything you need to consider, so you can confidently choose an e-bike that’s perfectly suited for your hunting adventures. We’ll explore the key factors that separate the real deal from the also-rans, ensuring you find the perfect electric companion for stalking game and hauling gear.

Range and Battery Life: How Far Can You Go?

Let’s face it, nobody wants to be stranded miles deep in the woods with a dead battery and a buck still to dress. That’s why range and battery life are absolutely crucial. Think about the typical distances you travel on your hunting trips. Are you typically riding a few miles in and out, or are you embarking on longer treks that cover significant ground? Knowing this will help you determine the battery capacity you need. Remember, advertised ranges are often based on ideal conditions, so factor in hills, payload, and assist level. Always err on the side of caution and choose a battery that offers more range than you think you’ll need.

Think about investing in an extra battery! It may seem like an added expense, but it could be a lifesaver, literally. Imagine being able to double your range, knowing you have a backup power source readily available. That peace of mind alone is worth the investment, especially when you’re venturing into remote areas where getting help isn’t an option. Besides, carrying an extra battery ensures you can explore further and stay out longer, maximizing your chances of a successful hunt. Consider it an insurance policy against a dead battery and a long, tiring walk back to camp. Some of the best electric bikes for hunting have great battery performance.

Motor Power and Torque: Conquering Tough Terrain

Now, let’s talk power. When you’re traversing rugged terrain, hauling hunting gear, or climbing steep hills, a wimpy motor just won’t cut it. You need a motor that can deliver sufficient power and torque to handle the challenges. Torque is especially important for accelerating from a standstill and tackling inclines. A higher torque rating means the motor can generate more rotational force, making it easier to overcome resistance. Think about the type of terrain you typically encounter. If you’re mostly riding on flat trails, a lower-powered motor might suffice. But if you’re dealing with hills, mud, or rocky paths, you’ll want a more robust motor that can handle the demands.

Consider the motor’s placement, too. Mid-drive motors, which are located near the pedals, tend to be more efficient and offer better weight distribution. This makes them ideal for tackling technical terrain. Hub motors, which are located in the front or rear wheel, are generally more affordable but may not offer the same level of performance on challenging surfaces. Ultimately, the best electric bikes for hunting need to handle the tough terrain. Don’t be afraid to test ride different e-bikes with varying motor power and torque ratings to see what feels right for you.

Tire Type and Suspension: A Smooth and Silent Ride

Next up: tires and suspension. These components play a vital role in both the comfort and performance of your e-bike. Fat tires, for example, are excellent for navigating soft terrain like sand, snow, or mud. Their wider profile provides better traction and stability. However, they can also be slower and less efficient on paved surfaces. Knobby tires are great for off-road adventures, providing excellent grip on loose dirt and rocks. But they can be noisy and wear down quickly on pavement. Consider the terrain you’ll be riding on most often and choose tires that are appropriate for those conditions.

Suspension is equally important, especially if you’re riding on rough trails. Front suspension forks can absorb bumps and vibrations, making for a more comfortable ride. Full suspension, which includes both front and rear suspension, provides even more cushioning and control. This is particularly beneficial if you’re carrying a heavy load or tackling really challenging terrain. The smoother and quieter your ride, the better your chances of sneaking up on game undetected. No one wants a noisy e-bike that announces their arrival to every deer in the county. Choosing the right tires and suspension makes a huge difference in finding the best electric bikes for hunting.

Load Capacity: Can It Handle Your Gear?

Let’s get practical. You’re not just riding an e-bike for fun; you’re using it to haul hunting gear. Think about everything you typically carry with you on a hunt: your rifle or bow, ammunition, hunting clothes, a backpack, water, snacks, and maybe even a deer stand. Add it all up, and that’s a significant amount of weight. Make sure the e-bike you choose has a sufficient load capacity to handle all of your gear, plus your own weight. Exceeding the load capacity can damage the e-bike and compromise your safety.

Consider the frame construction and components when evaluating load capacity. A sturdy frame and robust components are essential for handling heavy loads. Also, look for e-bikes that come equipped with racks or have the option to add them. Racks can be incredibly useful for carrying gear and distributing weight evenly. Don’t underestimate the importance of proper weight distribution. A poorly balanced load can make the e-bike difficult to handle, especially on uneven terrain. Spend some time experimenting with different gear configurations to find what works best for you. Some of the best electric bikes for hunting will make hauling your gear easy.

Stealth and Noise Reduction: Staying Undetected

Here’s a critical factor for hunting: stealth. The whole point of using an e-bike is to move silently through the woods, minimizing your impact on the environment and increasing your chances of spotting game. A noisy e-bike can spook animals and ruin your hunt. Look for e-bikes that are designed with stealth in mind. This might include features like a quiet motor, low-noise tires, and a camouflage finish.

Consider adding aftermarket accessories to further reduce noise. For example, you can wrap the frame with sound-dampening material or replace noisy components with quieter alternatives. Also, practice your riding technique. Avoid sudden acceleration and braking, which can create unwanted noise. Learn to anticipate obstacles and adjust your speed accordingly. The best electric bikes for hunting are quiet and blend into their surroundings. The quieter you are, the more successful your hunt will be.

Frame Size and Fit: Comfort is Key

Don’t overlook the importance of a proper fit. An e-bike that’s too big or too small can be uncomfortable and difficult to handle, especially on rough terrain. Spend some time getting professionally fitted. A bike shop can help you determine the right frame size based on your height and inseam. Also, consider the geometry of the frame. Some e-bikes have a more upright riding position, while others have a more aggressive, forward-leaning position.

Think about the type of riding you’ll be doing and choose a frame geometry that’s appropriate for those conditions. A more upright position is generally more comfortable for long rides, while a more aggressive position can provide better control and efficiency. Remember, comfort is key when you’re spending hours in the saddle. An uncomfortable e-bike can lead to fatigue and pain, which can negatively impact your hunt. Taking the time to find the right fit is well worth the investment. The best electric bikes for hunting should be comfortable and make your time outdoors enjoyable.

Price and Budget: Finding the Sweet Spot

Let’s talk money. Electric bikes can range in price from a few hundred dollars to several thousand. It’s important to set a budget before you start shopping and stick to it. Don’t be tempted to overspend on features you don’t need. However, don’t skimp on quality. A cheap e-bike may seem like a good deal at first, but it could end up costing you more in the long run if it breaks down or doesn’t perform well.

Consider the long-term costs of ownership. This includes things like battery replacement, maintenance, and repairs. A more expensive e-bike may have a longer lifespan and require less maintenance, making it a better value in the long run. Do your research and compare prices from different retailers. Look for sales and discounts. You might be able to find a great deal on a high-quality e-bike if you’re willing to shop around. When hunting for the best electric bikes for hunting, focus on finding that sweet spot where quality meets affordability.

FAQ

What are the main benefits of using an electric bike for hunting?

Electric bikes offer a ton of advantages for hunters! First off, they’re incredibly quiet. That means you can move through the woods with minimal disturbance to wildlife, increasing your chances of spotting your prey. Plus, they can easily handle tough terrains like muddy trails or steep hills, allowing you to access remote hunting spots you might otherwise have to walk a long way to reach.

Beyond the stealth and mobility, e-bikes can also carry your gear. Many models come with racks or attachments that allow you to transport your hunting equipment, like rifles, bows, and stands, without exhausting yourself before you even start hunting. You’ll save energy and be fresher when you finally reach your stand, which could make all the difference in your hunt.

How far can I expect to travel on a single charge with an e-bike?

That’s a great question, and the honest answer is, it depends! Several factors influence your range, including the battery capacity, the terrain you’re riding on, how much weight you’re carrying, and how much you rely on pedal assist versus the throttle. A general rule of thumb is that a good e-bike designed for hunting can give you anywhere from 20 to 50 miles on a single charge.

However, always overestimate your needs! It’s better to have extra battery life than to be stranded miles from your truck. Consider investing in an extra battery if you plan on doing long-range hunts or exploring areas with very challenging terrain. You can also adjust your riding style to conserve battery, like using lower assist levels and pedaling more yourself.

Are electric hunting bikes legal to use on public lands?

Ah, the million-dollar question! Regulations regarding e-bike use on public lands vary significantly depending on where you’re hunting. The best course of action is to always check with the specific agency that manages the land you intend to use. This could be the state’s Department of Natural Resources, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), or the U.S. Forest Service.

Don’t rely on hearsay or old information; regulations can change frequently. Look for official websites or contact local offices directly to get the most up-to-date rules on e-bike use, including where they’re allowed, what speed limits apply, and if there are any permit requirements. It’s much better to be safe than sorry and risk a fine or worse!

What kind of maintenance do electric hunting bikes require?

Luckily, maintaining an e-bike isn’t too complicated, but it does require a little more attention than a standard bicycle. Regular cleaning is essential, especially after riding through muddy or dusty conditions. Pay particular attention to the drivetrain (chain, gears) and use a bike-specific degreaser and lubricant to keep things running smoothly.

Besides cleaning, you’ll want to check your tire pressure regularly and inspect your brakes for wear and tear. The battery is another crucial component; store it in a cool, dry place when not in use and follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for charging. Finally, have your e-bike professionally serviced at least once a year to ensure all the electrical components are functioning correctly.

How much do electric hunting bikes typically cost?

Let’s be real, e-bikes designed for hunting are an investment. You can expect to pay anywhere from $2,000 to $7,000 or even more, depending on the quality of the components, battery capacity, motor power, and features. Entry-level models tend to be more affordable, but they may have limitations in terms of range, power, and durability.

Higher-end e-bikes often boast more powerful motors, longer-lasting batteries, better suspension, and sturdier frames, making them better suited for demanding hunting conditions. Consider your budget and your specific hunting needs. A mid-range model might offer the best balance of price and performance for many hunters.

Are electric hunting bikes noisy and will they spook game?

One of the biggest draws of e-bikes for hunting is their quiet operation! Compared to ATVs or trucks, they’re remarkably silent. Most e-bikes use electric motors that produce minimal noise, especially at lower assist levels. However, some components, like the tires on certain terrains, might create some sound.

To minimize noise further, choose an e-bike with quiet tires designed for off-road use. Avoid using the throttle extensively, as it can generate more noise than pedal assist. Pay attention to your riding habits and be mindful of your surroundings. Approaching hunting spots slowly and deliberately will help reduce the chances of spooking game, regardless of your mode of transportation.

Can I convert my existing mountain bike into an electric hunting bike?

Absolutely! Converting a standard mountain bike into an e-bike is a viable option and can often be more cost-effective than buying a purpose-built e-bike. Conversion kits typically include a motor, battery, controller, and display, and they’re designed to be relatively easy to install. However, make sure your existing bike is sturdy enough to handle the added weight and power of the electric components.

Choosing the right conversion kit is key. Consider the type of motor (hub motor or mid-drive motor), the battery voltage and capacity, and the compatibility with your bike’s frame and components. A mid-drive motor generally provides better performance and weight distribution but can be more expensive. It’s also wise to have a professional bike mechanic inspect your conversion to ensure everything is installed correctly and safely.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it! Your journey to finding the best electric bikes for hunting shouldn’t feel overwhelming anymore. Armed with this guide, you’re now equipped to navigate the market, understand the specs, and identify which e-bike aligns perfectly with your hunting needs and preferences. Think about those quiet mornings in the woods, the effortless climbs, and the expanded range you’ll have to explore those previously unreachable hunting spots. Picture yourself gliding through the terrain, silently tracking your game, and making the most of every hunt.

Now it’s time to take the leap! Don’t hesitate to invest in the best electric bikes for hunting that will revolutionize your hunting experience. Go forth, explore the wilderness, and make those unforgettable memories. Adventure awaits!

Leave a Comment